Table 1

Covariate distributions prior to the propensity score match, after the match, as well as in the remaining unmatched CONCORDE Bullet treated patients

CovariateTotal study populationAfter propensity matchUnmatched exposures
CONCORDE BulletAlternate IVBICONCORDE BulletAlternate IVBICONCORDE Bullet
(N=136)(N=98)Std. diff(N=69)(N=69)Std. diff(N=67)Std. diff
Female52.94%52.04%0.01850.72%55.07%0.08755.22%0.090
Age—median (IQR)61.84±12.4358.87±13.160.23260.32±13.3060.09±13.880.01763.40±11.360.249
Body mass index—median (IQR)30.03±5.6929.29±5.800.13029.86±5.5229.75±6.130.01730.21±5.890.062
Diabetes13.97%10.20%0.11614.49%10.14%0.13313.43%0.031
Heart failure0.74%1.02%0.0311.45%1.45%0.0000.00%
Coronary artery disease4.41%4.08%0.0164.35%4.35%0.0004.48%0.006
Smoker (active)13.24%8.16%0.1658.70%8.70%0.00017.91%0.274
Preoperative opioid Rx19.12%27.55%0.20024.64%18.84%0.14113.43%0.288
ASA class 1–268.38%72.45%0.08966.67%75.36%0.19370.15%0.075
ASA class 3–531.62%27.55%0.08933.33%24.64%0.19329.85%0.075
Prior spine surgery0.74%0.00%0.00%0.00%1.49%
Single-level40.44%44.90%0.09057.97%55.07%0.05922.39%0.779
Two-level0.00%1.02%0.00%0.00%0.00%
Complex repair (>2 levels)40.44%6.12%0.8897.25%8.70%0.05474.63%1.881
No level identified19.12%47.96%0.64234.78%36.23%0.0302.99%0.889
Surgeon volume low5.15%27.55%0.6368.70%11.59%0.0961.49%0.332
Surgeon volume medium72.79%64.29%0.18475.36%76.81%0.03470.15%0.117
Surgeon volume high22.06%8.16%0.39615.94%11.59%0.12628.36%0.302
  • ASA class, American Society of Anesthesiology physical status classification; IVBI, intervertebral body implant; Std. diff, standard difference.